Reaffirmation Day


Date: Fri, 10 Aug 2001
Subject: Tradition?
From: Pat Taylor
To: 1955 usna

Caught a little off guard when Denny and Tom promulgated what I thought to be a "new initiative" some 10 days ago...re the incoming class Reaffirmation Day coming up tomorrow, Sat. 11 August. Wondering if this also stemmed from the Naval Academy Chaplain's Office - I made some inquiries of those classes that came before us as to where this was born...and why. Responses to my question indicate that maybe Reaffirmation Day goes back three years. I couldn't pin that down. It is certainly a relatively new Event , and has been added onto the program known as Parents Day.

I vaguely remember we had a Parents Day toward the end of Plebe Summer, when almost every Fourth Class Midshipman acquired a "sister" that tagged along with a visiting parent. The Administration was certainly aware of an awful lot of sisters holding hands with their Plebe "brothers" that Saturday afternoon!

Anyway, as we have seen from the events asked for, this year's Parents Day has a Parade, accompanied by another Swearing In. What follows is an account of last year's event, as told to me by one of the class officers from an earlier year group; I will refrain from any comment other than to say it bodes to be another scorcher so I think I'll miss tomorrow's Parade. Maybe someone knows what the plebe class "Sea Trials" referred to below is all about. If traditions are building, our class may receive another invitation to another event?

"...a dozen of us, with a few wives from the Annapolis area showed up on Worden Field to see what was going on. First time I had ever viewed a P-rade under a tent along with the "brass". Was explained during the ceremony that the reaffirmation of the original oath of office was for the mids to have chance to back out if they didn't really mean it. (no-one did). And it was Parents Weekend with parents lined around the field. 2 or 3 First Class Brigade Officers with a blue and gold "honor stick" (looked liked something they had pulled out of a swamp - about 6 ft long X 4 in dia. dead wood) waved the thing around and talked about the honor concept.

I was impressed with the march-on. They looked much better than the Brigade marching on field to football games. Was surprised about the whole thing -- primarily that the first oath holds little water and that they're given a second chance -- after all the plebe summer grilling -- to say they mean it. Was impressed with the looks of the plebe class. And, their response, as a group to questions. The Commandant, unfortunately, lost his voice but his speech was picked up by a CDR. assistant (sharp guy) who was son of one of my classmates from FL who was there. Our class VP gave a short speech on the meaning of honor. He had no idea what to talk about but someone gave him a "business card" which had the current honor concept briefly defined on it and he made a speech around that. Did a good job.

After the ceremony, ( we were invited ) to his home -- brick house behind Worden. Got to meet and talk to the Supe, Commandant and Dep. Commandant..."

" (our class ) was invited by Alumni Assoc. to attend ( the Plebe Class) "Sea Trials" ... so I sent an e-mail to Washington Metro Classmates asking the pussy whipped bunch of old wimps to show up at North Severn and observe it. Only one did a retired USMC Col. joined me. I was particularly interested in seeing how the girls did. Not well. Some had to be helped over the obstacles, and "crutches" were made for them to use if they couldn't jump high enough to catch rail and pull themselves up. "


From: "Frederic L. Tolleson"
To: "BOBBY FREEMAN"; "TOM LAPHAM"
Date: Saturday, August 11, 2001 7:18 PM
Subject: AUGUST 11 CEREMONEY AT USNA

Message removed at Fred's request.

EX SCIENTA TRIDENTS

SEMPER FIDELIS,
FRED TOLLESON



From: "Jim & Fran Perryman"
To: "Frederic L. Tolleson"
Cc: "USNA55 Listserve"
Subject: Re: AUGUST 11 CEREMONY AT USNA
Date: Sat, 11 Aug 2001

Great words, Fred!

Was sitting at my computer, after an interesting drive back to Haymarket
from Annapolis (mucho thunderstorms), reflecting on today's Reaffirmation at
USNA, when your email came on line.

After all the heated discussions by our '55 email listers and the anti-USNA
stuff almost daily in the Washington Post, I wasn't sure that I really
wanted to attend the celebration of '05's completion of their Plebe Summer.
Despite the facts that the Chesapeake Bay Bridge was shut down for most of
the morning due to HAZMAT (Tom K's wife was thoughtful enough to call us
early with a warning) and the traffic across the Potomac River Bridge was
its usual disaster, I'm really glad Fran and I made the trip!

A few observations/thoughts:

Upon our approaching the Academy grounds at the North Gate, a Marine sentry
greeted us with a snappy salute and a pleasant "Good Morning, Sir"!  When I
responded with "Good Morning, Marine; how are you today?", his reply was
"Absolutely outstanding, Sir!"  As I passed though, he apparently observed
my "USMC Semper Fidelis" license plate and gave me an "OohRaah!"  Now, for a
jarhead, how could my day not have gone well!?

On the parade field the Middies looked sharp, and, despite the heat and
humidity, and their standing at attention throughout the speeches
(regrettably, not one leader in the reviewing stand thought to give their
troops "parade rest" at best, or more appropriately "at ease"), I didn't see
one man or woman escorted off to the waiting ambulances!

As for the mental/spiritual health of the Brigade (ethics, morals, etc.),
I'm reassured that those who follow us by 50 years are every bit as sincere,
capable, and dedicated as we were.  In my opinion the "diversity" thing is
overdone, but in light of our country's current social frame of mind and the
resultant politics, I don't see how our USNA leaders could do any better and
survive!!!

For all info addees, my thanks to Denny S and Tom K for making this day a
very memorable one for Fran and me.  BTW, I took a number of digital shots
of the day's events and will email them to anyone interested.  So's not to
overload everyone's email boxes, I've attached what I hope represents an
acceptable amount of computer memory (simply had to include the shot of
'55's greatest GRUNT!)

Regards,
Jim Perryman

Grunt

Aught5

FiftyFive


From: "John Tyler"
To: "Jim & Fran Perryman", "Frederic L. Tolleson"
Subject: Re: AUGUST 11 CEREMONY AT USNA
Date: Sun, 12 Aug 2001
Cc: "USNA55 Listserve"

Jim,

AMEN.  A great e-mail and pictures.  I am so far out of touch however, I
don't know who the greatest grunt is, but do believe he has a fine profile.
I am passing your e-mail to the president of the Arizona Parents Club.  They
do a great job here and I couldn't agree with you more that the incoming
class are the same as us, only fifty years later!  Things do change. I don't
understand why some of our classmates have a hard-on for USNA.  We had folks
that were married (and had children, too!) when they graduated, I remember
the guy that pulled the fire alarm in DC and was caught, selling of stuff
which a gentleman wasn't supposed to do, illegal betting (football
pools...who made the money?), a year book published with a page that could
be easily removed that had a picture of a midshipman that others didn't like
many years ago before our time, etc, etc, etc. All my heroes weren't/aren't
saints but they won battles and wars. And as far as I am concerned the
Academy was and is a gem in America's crown.



From: "Guy Grafius"
To: "Perryman, Jim '55-10"
Sent: Sunday, August 12, 2001 12:47 PM
Subject: August 11 USNA
Cc: "Kiefaber, Tom '55-19"; "Dennis J. Sullivan"; "John T Tyler"

Fran & Jim,

Any and all photos would be appreciated.  Does anybody have a list of
who attended?  Eileen & Tom Copeman (10) are visiting for the weekend.
Several sets of dimmed eyeballs have glanced at the photo of the '55
group you sent.  We can't even recognize more than about 20%.

Pat & Guy Grafius (10)
Scottsdale, AZ



From: "Jim & Fran Perryman"
To: "Guy Grafius"
Subject: Re: August 11 USNA
Date: Sun, 12 Aug 2001
Cc: "USNA55 Listserve"

Pat & Guy,

You, too!  At my age about the only folks I could recognize were me and my
wife!!  Thanks to Tom Kiefaber, here's the line-up (ref the photo I sent) -
left to right from the Admiral & "MG"  are:  Robin Pirie, Kent Drummond,
Jack McNish, Steve Lowe, Jim Carr, George Atkins, Paul Grozen, Hank Mustin,
Don Conner, Ray Hine, Dick Peterson, John Adams, Don Kellerman, Fred Tolleson
('55's greatest Grunt), me, John Haynes, Denny Sullivan, Tom McIsaac, Tom
Kiefaber, Ed Lull, Hartley Holte, Bob Miller, and Fred Underwood.  Attending,
I'm told, but lost and not forgotten were George Martin, Fred Schoenberger
and Tom Cann!

Have received a number of positive emails and phone calls from our
classmates following my email (they meant a LOT to me); have chosen to quote
a part of one from a sword-bearer at Fran's and my 6/4/55 USNA Chapel
wedding:
"...I am passing your e-mail to the president of the Arizona Parents Club.
They do a great job here and I couldn't agree with you more that the incoming
class are the same as us, only fifty years later...all my heroes weren't/aren't saints but they won battles and wars, and as far as I am concerned, the Academy was and is a gem in America's crown."
For those of you who have asked for more of my photos, I'm working on that.
Don't hold your breath, 'cause they aren't spectacular!

Been an emotionally satisfying weekend for the Perrymans!

Our best to all you guys and your gals, past and present!

Jim/Fran



From: Kief55
Date: Sun, 12 Aug 2001 23:51 EDT
Subject: Reaffirmation Day - After Action Report
To: usna55

AFTER ACTION REPORT - REAFFIRMATION DAY CEREMONY - AUGUST 11, 2001

Our Class was invited by the Superintendent to attend the Reaffirmation Day
Ceremony of the Class of 2005 (by the Class of 1955) held yesterday.
Twenty-five classmates accepted the invitation.  A commemorative coin was
presented to the Plebe Brigade Commander by Hank Mustin (all in the Class of
2005 received one, as did all of us present).  The coin reads, on one side:
Class of 2005 - HONOR, SHIP, SHIPMATE, SELF - presented by the Class of 1955;
and on the other side: UNITED STATES NAVAL ACADEMY with Academy Seal.
Following brief remarks by our Class President, Denny Sullivan, Hank Mustin
delivered a stirring address that brought EVERYONE to their feet afterwards.
 
It done us proud:

Good afternoon. I'm looking across the field to the cemetery at Hospital
Point, where those of my family who went before me now rest. My great
grandfather was Class of 1873, my grandfather 1896, my father 1932, and my
uncle 1933. Also, but not there yet, my brother is 1962 and my son is 1990.
Based on all this, we claim  a world's record of dubious distinction: most
family hours marching in P-rades on Worden Field.

Fifty years ago, in the hot Annapolis summer of 1951, my classmates and I
stood where you now stand. We had the same problems you have: how to remember
which is port and which is starboard, how to figure out what time it is when
someone says "1600 hours", and how to absorb the baffling and mysterious
Plebe Rates in Reef Points. And, although we didn't know it, among us were
standing a future Secretary of the Navy, an Astronaut, a US Ambassador,
giants of industry and medicine, as well as Admirals, Generals, heroes of hot
and cold war, a Rhodes Scholar, All-American athletes, and Olympic champions..
If the past is any kind of prologue, the same kinds of greatness stand in
your ranks today, and you will reflect the same kind of credit on the Naval
Academy.

Lots of things have changed since that summer of 1951. For openers, there was
a war in Korea, and recent graduates of both the Naval Academy and West Point
were fighting it in the front lines. There was no such thing as color TV, no
cell phones, no PC's or E-Mail, no stereo and no compact discs. Steak,
cheese, butter, bacon and eggs were considered health foods. Everybody
smoked; a pack of sea stores cigarettes cost less than a dime. Nobody had
ever heard of Elvis or the Beetles, and "N-Sync" and the Dixie Chicks had
not been born. America's closest allies included Cuba, Iran, and Libya. In
the navy, there were no nuclear powered aircraft carriers or submarines. In
fact, there are aircraft in the fleet today that can fly faster straight up
than ours could fly straight down. There were no digital computers, no cruise
missiles, no laser guided bombs, and no air conditioning in our ships. If a
young lady spent the night in Bancroft Hall or in a ship, somebody was going
to be in serious trouble. We got three dollars a payday; there were six wings
in Bancroft Hall, no Halsey Field House, no Lejeune Hall, no Rickover Hall,
no Nimitz Library, and no Navy-Marine Corps Memorial Stadium. Navy was a
national football power.

But the fundamentals, the bedrock principles of the Naval Academy, haven't
changed at all. Those principles, as they've been stressed by Admirals Ryan
and Locklear, are honor, integrity, loyalty and moral courage. Those concepts
sometimes fall out of favor with the intelligentsia when times are good,
they're not considered "cool" or sophisticated in a "if it feels good, do
it" environment. But Academy graduates who have followed those principles
have served our country well since the Academy was founded, and that includes
times in war when nothing less than the fate of the nation was on the line,
and times in peace when giant Fortune 500 companies led by Academy graduates
could either succeed or fail.

Why haven't they changed? The answer is simple: the Brigade of Midshipmen and
the long chain of Naval Academy alumni have insisted, indeed demanded, that
they stand. And now you, each one of you in Ought 5, you are links in that
chain. (Among you are three grandchildren from my Class). And, as that
irritating TV show loudly reminds us ad nauseam, a chain is only as strong as
its weakest link. Like it or not, each of you now has personal
responsibilities as a custodian of those principles: honor, integrity,
loyalty and moral courage.

In 2051, one of you will stand here looking at the Class of 2055, and believe
me, that will be a lot sooner than you think. The lay out of the Academy will
be different, American society will be different, and the military will have
strange and wondrous capabilities that I can't even imagine. You are going to
need stars by which to navigate through the uncharted waters of the future,
stars that will not dim their light as the years pass. You have been taught
the names of those stars: honor, integrity, loyalty and moral courage. Follow
them, and you can pass them on to the Class of 2055 just as the Class of 1955
passes them on to you.

Good luck, and Beat Army.

After the ceremony, forty-five of us adjourned for lunch to the Severn Room
in Bancroft Hall where we were joined by the Superintendent, VADM John Ryan
'67 and the President of USNAAA, George Watt '73, and their wives.

Classmates attending were: John & Debbie Adams, George Atkins + four guests,
Jim Carr + three guests, Don & Ginny Conner, Kent & Patricia Drummond, Paul &
Phyllis Grozen, John B. Haynes + one guest, Ray Hine & Virginia Wyman,
Hartley Holte, Don & Nancy Kellerman, Tom Kiefaber, Steve & Shirley Lowe, Ed
Lull, Tom McIsaac, Jack & Joan McNish, George W. Martin, Bob Miller, Hank &
Lucy Mustin, Jim & Fran Perryman, Dick Peterson, Robin Pirie, Fred & Nora
Schoenberger, Denny Sullivan, Fred Tolleson, and Fred & Maude Underwood.
Glenn Arthur, Hugh Webster and Phil Monahan were unable to attend at the last
minute.

We had the opportunity to meet members of the Class of 2005 after the
ceremony.  They were impressive in every regard. A good start!
  


To: usna55
Date: Mon, 13 Aug 2001
Subject: Re affirmation day,
From: "Fred S. Underwood"

Denny and Tom did a super job having me organized.  I appreciated that.
There were three things that struck me about the visit.

First.  We went to the P-Rade at 0900.  It was the first P-Rade I had
ever seen.  It brought back a flood of memories of our participation in
such events.

Second.  Those M1's with bayonet fixed certainly did get heavy during a
fifteen gun salute.  Didn't we do 21 guns once for Harry Truman?

Third.  thank god the tropical worsted kaki are gone.  It was terribly
hot and muggy out there.  I can clearly picture the mid in his
undershirt, brown shirt, black neck tie, single breasted coat, and GREAT
BIG SWEAT CIRCLES  under each arm.

It was a good visit.  I was glad I went.

Fred Underwood (22)



Date: Mon, 13 Aug 2001
From: Robert Rice
Subject: Re: Re affirmation day,
To: "Fred S. Underwood", usna55

Fred, your comment about the tropical worsted kaki uniforms being no longer a part of the dress of midshipmen (and maybe U. S. Naval Officers) I was wondering what makes up the dress of midshipmen these days?  From 1955 to 2001 is a few years and things do change from time to time.

Bob Rice



From: "Norm Harper"
To: "NA Class of 55"
Subject: Bravo Zulu
Date: Mon, 13 Aug 2001

Bravo Zulu to Denny, Tom, Hank and the rest of the class that took the time and effort to be at Reaffirmation Day.

Hank's words were short, inspirational and to the point.

Couldn't help but think that being part of the solution may be the only real answer to all the concerns registered on this listserv.

Norm (4)



From: RMieldazis
Date: Mon, 13 Aug 2001 12:50:45 EDT
Subject: Re: AUGUST 11 CEREMONY AT USNA
To: jimpman, usna55

JIM, I'M SORRY THAT I AM NOT CLOSER TO THE USNA ACTIVITIES BUT I AGREE WITH YOU 100% ON YOUR ASSESSMENT OF THE MIDSHIPMEN. BY THE WAY WHO ARE ALL THOSE OLD FOLKS  IN THE '55 GROUP PHOTO?

BEST WISHES, DICK MIELDAZIS



From: "Dan Butterfield"
To: DSull55
Subject: Hank Mustin Reaffirmation Ceremony Words
Date: Tue, 14 Aug 2001
Cc: USNA55

Denny, Kief...

I've heard so many praising comments regarding Hank Mustin's spoken words to
Class of 2005 apparently given at the Reaffirmation Ceremony that I was hoping
to get hold of a copy.

Any chance of a transcript or something?

Thanks for all of us interested.

Dan



From: ClaSummers
Date: Tue, 14 Aug 2001 23:29:59 EDT
Subject: Aug 11 Ceremony at USNA
To: USNA55

Thanks to all of you for going and representing us.

Looked good.

Although, I do hope the picture of you in your undersized suits did not scare
too many of the nervous plebes out of the Navy.

Thanks again.

Bud Summers 18/02

P. S.  Who do you refer to as the grunt???